Knitting vs. Crochet: Anything You Can Do, I Can Do Better?
“Anything you can do, I can do better. I can do anything better than you.”
Does anyone still recognize this song? I remember singing it with my younger sister a lot when we were kids. If you’re not familiar, the song is called “Anything You Can Do (I Can Do Better),” written by Irving Berlin for the 1946 musical Annie Get Your Gun. If you’re okay with having a catchy song stuck in your head for a few hours, I highly recommend giving it a listen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WO23WBji_Z0
This song comes to mind whenever I see and hear discussions about the differences between knitting and crochet.
Both knitting and crochet are methods of creating fabric. In reality, there are only two differences between the two:
The tools used:
Knitting uses two needles, and crochet uses a single hook. Because the tools are different, the stitches are made using different techniques.The fabric created:
Because the techniques are different, the resulting fabrics have different characteristics and qualities.
So which is better?
NEITHER! Knitting is not “better” than crochet, and crochet is not “better” than knitting. They are just different. Each can do everything that the other can.
Some people suggest pros and cons for each craft as a way to decide which is “better.” While there can be some truth in those ideas, they are often more nuanced than they first appear.
Common belief #1: Crochet is “faster” than knitting
There is some truth to this. Many have tested this by crocheting and knitting similar items using the same yarn and hook or needle size. Almost always, the crocheted item is finished “faster” than the knitted item. This is because crochet stitches are often taller than knitted stitches.
My response:
Note that I’m putting “faster” in quotation marks. The truth is, there are fast crocheters and slow crocheters—the same goes for knitters. Everyone works at a different pace. The idea that crochet is “faster” than knitting insinuates that there is some sort of race to win. Aren’t we already moving fast enough in our regular lives? Instead, I prefer to frame both crafts as a way to slow down.
Common belief #2: Crochet uses more yarn
Just like the “crochet is faster” argument, many have tested this theory in the same way. In most cases, the crocheted project used more yarn. Again, this is because of the way the stitches are made.
My response:
While this belief does have some truth to it, it can be discouraging to someone who would like to learn but may be on a tight budget. The real truth is that crochet can be as expensive—or as inexpensive—as you’d like.
Common belief #3: Knitting requires more tools
It can. This largely depends on what is being made. Some projects require special tools such as cable needles, double-pointed needles, or a specific length or size of circular needle.
My response:
I refer you to my previous response. You do not need to purchase every tool to enjoy knitting. Knitting can also be as expensive or as inexpensive as you’d like.
Common belief #4: Knitting requires high-end wool and other natural fibers
This largely depends on what you are making. It is always best to select the best fiber for the project. Dishcloths are best made with cotton yarn, while wool is a great choice for sweaters.
My response:
When selecting yarn for a project, I always recommend choosing a fiber that matches both your project and your budget. However, fiber choice is also highly personal. Some people are allergic to wool, and some have sensory sensitivities that may prevent them from using certain fibers. Plus, a large percentage of store-bought clothing is made from synthetic fibers like polyester, nylon, and acrylic. It’s absolutely fine to make a wearable item with acrylic yarn.
Common belief #5: Knitting is better for garments. Crochet is better for toys
My response:
This is an old-school way of thinking. Pattern design for both crafts has evolved significantly over the last few decades.
Common belief #6: It’s easier to fix mistakes in crochet
My response:
Okay, I admit that this one is 100% true. Since crochet stitches are fully completed one at a time, there’s no worry about dropping stitches (a common concern in knitting). However, the most common way to fix mistakes in crochet is to frog, or undo, back to the location of the mistake. This could mean undoing hours of work. Since knit stitches are linked together, mistakes can often be fixed without ripping out several rows of stitches. While this can be trickier, it can also save a lot of time.
So how do you determine which craft is right for you? This simply comes down to personal preference.
Here are a couple of questions to ask yourself to help you choose.
#1 – What do you want to make?
When you think of these crafts, what is the first project that comes to mind? A cozy sweater? A colorful blanket? A plush toy? Take some time to find pictures of these items, both knitted and crocheted. There are likely some differences in their appearance. Which is more appealing to you?
Beware of AI-generated images that are starting to dominate image searches. AI images do not show true stitches and can be very deceiving to beginners. I recommend searching Ravelry.com for patterns and projects instead. You’ll need an account, but it’s free and only requires an email address.
#2 – Why do you want to learn?
Are you looking for a challenge? Do you want something to relax your mind and keep your hands away from your phone? Are you interested in making handmade gifts? Maybe you’d like to give back to the community by donating your finished items?
#3 – Consider your physical needs
It may seem odd to think of knitting and crochet as physical activities, but they absolutely are. Both rely on fine motor skills and small, repetitive movements that can affect the fingers, wrists, elbows, shoulders, and neck. Whichever craft you choose should feel comfortable. If working with two needles and yarn feels overwhelming, crochet may be a better fit. If the larger wrist motion of crochet is uncomfortable, knitting—which can involve smaller movements—may be a better option. Modifications can be made in both knitting and crochet to support comfort and reduce strain.
So, which should you pick? Honestly, it doesn’t matter—start with whatever feels fun. You might discover a love for crochet’s rhythm or knitting’s meditative flow. Or maybe you’ll fall for both. The most important thing is to make something, enjoy the journey, and let your hands do the talking.
